Important: This is a mathematical comparison using the assumptions you enter. It is not personalised financial advice and it is not a prediction of investment performance. Investment returns, charges and future tax rules are uncertain, and they may change before you access your money.

Pension vs ISA Calculator

Compare putting the same amount of take-home pay into a pension or an ISA. Contribution relief, growth and withdrawal tax are worked out in separate stages, using only the figures you enter.

Contribution
Check your contribution qualifies for relief. Personal tax relief is generally limited to 100% of your relevant UK earnings or £3,600 gross a year, whichever is higher. This calculator does not verify that your contribution qualifies, so make sure the amount you enter qualifies for the assumed relief. The gross contribution, which is what counts towards the limit, is shown in the breakdown.

Enter the amount you personally pay into your pension before any higher-rate tax relief reclaim. Your provider adds basic-rate relief automatically.

The rate you pay on the top slice of your income. It is assumed to apply to the whole contribution, so if your contribution crosses a tax band, the higher-rate relief you actually receive can differ. Not sure of your rate? Check the Income Tax Calculator.

Growth

Whole years, 1 to 60. Contributions are paid at the end of each year in both routes, so the first one earns no growth in year one.

Applied equally to the pension and the ISA before charges. It is not a forecast and returns can be lower or negative.

Subtracted from the growth rate each year. Leave blank for 0%.

Subtracted from the growth rate each year. Leave blank for 0%.

If entered, results are also shown in today’s money. Leave blank to skip.

Withdrawal

How much tax-free lump sum allowance you have left. Your pension provider can tell you. Enter 0 if none remains. The standard allowance for 2026/27 is £268,275; check GOV.UK for the current figure.

The average Income Tax rate you expect on the pension withdrawal above the tax-free amount. The whole pot is treated as taken at once, so if you would spread withdrawals, enter your expected average rate.

Only used for an approximate warning about the minimum pension age at the end of the period. It is not a definitive eligibility check.

This is a mathematical comparison using your own assumptions. It is not personalised financial advice or a prediction of investment performance. Investment returns, charges and future tax treatment are uncertain.

Projected pension and ISA values

  • Pension pot
  • ISA balance
  • Pension after assumed withdrawal tax

Contribution, growth and withdrawal breakdown

Year-by-year projection

The last column is hypothetical. It shows what the pension would be worth if the whole pot were withdrawn in that year under the same tax-free lump sum and withdrawal tax assumptions. It is not a tax deducted each year.

Withdrawal tax sensitivity

Only the withdrawal tax rate changes in this table. Everything else stays as you entered it.

How this calculator works: The same effective yearly cost goes into each route, paid at the end of each year with identical timing. The pension route adds tax relief to reach a gross contribution, grows it at your growth rate less the pension charge, then applies the tax-free lump sum (the lower of 25% and your remaining Lump Sum Allowance) and your assumed tax rate on the rest. The ISA route invests the same effective cost at your growth rate less the ISA charge, with tax-free withdrawals. Employer contributions, the Lifetime ISA, annual allowance checks and Scottish tax bands are not modelled. Tax rules can change, so check GOV.UK before making decisions.

Pension vs ISA Calculator UK

This Pension vs ISA Calculator compares paying the same amount of take-home pay into a pension or into an ISA, using only the contributions, growth, charges and tax assumptions you enter. Instead of two columns of compound interest, it works through the pension in separate stages: the tax relief on the way in, growth inside the wrapper, and the tax-free lump sum and tax on the way out.

How the comparison works

  1. Contribution: you enter what you pay in each year and how the pension contribution is paid. The calculator works out the gross amount that reaches the pension after relief, and your effective yearly cost.
  2. Growth: both routes grow at the same assumed rate, less a charge you set for each. Contributions are paid at the end of each year in both, so the timing is identical.
  3. Withdrawal: the pension pays up to 25% tax-free, limited by your remaining Lump Sum Allowance. The rest is reduced by the tax rate you enter. ISA withdrawals are tax-free.
  4. Result: you see the net spendable value of each route, the difference, and the break-even withdrawal tax rate.

Pension and ISA at a glance

FeaturePensionISA
Tax relief on contributionsYes, through Income Tax relief. How it is given depends on the method.No
Growth inside the wrapperFree of UK Income Tax and Capital Gains TaxFree of UK Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax
WithdrawalsUsually up to 25% tax-free, limited by the Lump Sum Allowance. The rest is taxed as income.Tax-free
AccessNot normally before the minimum pension age (55, rising to 57 from 6 April 2028)Generally at any time, except products such as fixed-term or Lifetime ISAs
Annual limitsAnnual allowance and relief limits apply£20,000 across all ISAs in 2026/27

How tax relief is treated

MethodGross contributionEffective cost to you
Relief at sourceYour payment divided by 0.8Your payment, less any higher-rate relief you claim
Net payYour cost divided by (1 minus your marginal Income Tax rate)Your cost
Salary sacrificeYour cost divided by (1 minus your Income Tax rate minus your employee National Insurance rate)Your cost, after Income Tax and employee National Insurance savings

Employer National Insurance savings are never counted, because whether any of that is passed on depends on your employer.

What this calculator does not model

  • Employer contributions: use the Workplace Pension Calculator.
  • The Lifetime ISA: see the Lifetime ISA Calculator.
  • Annual allowance, MPAA and carry forward: see the Pension Tax Relief Calculator. The calculator also does not check whether your contribution qualifies for relief, which is generally limited to the higher of 100% of your relevant UK earnings and £3,600 gross a year.
  • Tax bands: you enter your own marginal and withdrawal rates, so no Scottish or other band engine is applied.
  • Drawing income over many years: see the Pension Drawdown Calculator.
  • Existing balances, rising contributions, the State Pension, benefit effects and protected allowances.
  • Inheritance Tax: the government has announced changes to how unused pension funds are treated from April 2027. This calculator does not model inheritance. From 6 April 2029, only the first £2,000 of salary-sacrificed pension contributions each year is exempt from National Insurance. That change is not modelled, so salary sacrifice National Insurance savings may be overstated over long periods. Check GOV.UK for the current position.

Frequently asked questions

Is a pension or an ISA better?

Neither is better in every case. The result depends on the assumptions you enter: how much tax relief you get going in, how your investments grow, the charges you pay, how much of the pension is tax-free and the tax you pay when you take money out. This calculator shows how those assumptions change the outcome. It is not advice on which to choose.

How does the calculator make the comparison fair?

Both routes cost you the same effective amount each year. For the pension, the calculator works out the gross contribution that amount buys after tax relief. For the ISA, the same effective amount is invested with no relief. Both use the same growth rate and the same contribution timing, with separate charges you can set.

How are relief at source, net pay and salary sacrifice treated?

With relief at source your provider adds basic-rate relief (20%), so the pension receives your payment divided by 0.8. Any further higher-rate relief has to be claimed, and you choose whether it is counted. With net pay, the gross contribution is your cost divided by one minus your marginal Income Tax rate. With salary sacrifice, the gross amount is your cost divided by one minus your Income Tax rate and your employee National Insurance rate, because both are saved. Employer National Insurance savings are never counted. Your marginal rate is assumed to apply to the whole contribution, so if the contribution crosses a tax band the relief you actually receive can differ. For relief at source, the calculator does not check that your contribution qualifies for relief, which is generally limited to the higher of 100% of your relevant UK earnings and £3,600 gross a year.

How is the tax-free lump sum worked out?

The tax-free amount is the lower of 25% of the pension pot and your remaining Lump Sum Allowance. The rest of the pot is the taxable amount, and the withdrawal tax rate you enter is applied to it. Net pension proceeds are the tax-free amount plus the taxable amount after that tax. Protected allowances and other special cases are not modelled.

Why do I enter my remaining Lump Sum Allowance?

The standard Lump Sum Allowance is a lifetime limit on tax-free lump sums, and some people have already used part of it. Entering what is left avoids overstating the tax-free amount. You can use the standard-allowance button if you have not taken any tax-free lump sums, and you should check the current figure on GOV.UK.

When are contributions assumed to be paid?

Contributions are assumed to be paid at the end of each year, in both the pension and the ISA. The first contribution therefore earns no growth in year one, and the final contribution is paid on the last day. Using the same timing for both routes keeps the comparison consistent.

What is the break-even withdrawal tax rate?

It is the tax rate on the taxable part of the pension withdrawal at which the pension and the ISA finish with the same spendable amount. If your assumed rate is below it, the pension finishes ahead. If it is above, the ISA finishes ahead. If one route is ahead at every rate, the calculator says there is no break-even.

Can I get at pension money as early as ISA money?

Not normally. An ISA can generally be accessed at any time, apart from products such as fixed-term or Lifetime ISAs. A private pension usually cannot be accessed before the minimum pension age, currently 55 and rising to 57 from 6 April 2028. If you enter your age, the calculator gives an approximate warning when the end of the period looks to fall below the minimum pension age expected to apply by then. It is not a definitive eligibility check.

Does this include employer contributions or the Lifetime ISA?

No. Employer contributions are left out because whether they are paid depends on your scheme, and the Lifetime ISA is left out because its bonus and withdrawal rules need a separate comparison. Use the Workplace Pension Calculator for employer contributions and the Lifetime ISA Calculator for the Lifetime ISA.