!
Check your mortgage terms before overpaying. Many mortgage deals limit how much you can overpay without an early repayment charge. This calculator does not model early repayment charges or overpayment limits, so confirm the rules with your lender first. Results are illustrative estimates, not financial advice.

Overpay Mortgage or Invest/Save Calculator

Compare the guaranteed interest you save by overpaying with what the same money could grow to elsewhere after tax and charges. Every rate is your own assumption, so nothing is pre-filled.

Your mortgage (repayment mortgages only)

£

% a year

Interest is charged monthly at one-twelfth of this annual rate.

years

months

£

Leave blank to use the payment calculated from your balance, rate and term. If you enter one, it is checked against those figures.

The money you could use

£

Spare money each month, on top of your mortgage payment.

£

years

Leave blank to compare at the end of the remaining mortgage term. It cannot be longer than the term.

The invest/save alternative

% a year

Your own assumption, applied as a steady annual return. Real returns vary and can be negative.

% a year

Platform and fund charges. Leave blank for none.

A simplified model: this rate is applied to growth each year, after charges. It is not the exact tax treatment of any ISA, savings account, investment or pension. Savings interest, dividends and capital gains are taxed differently and allowances vary, so choose another rate if these do not fit. Check GOV.UK for current rules.

Turned off: once a mortgage is cleared, the money that was going to it is treated as spent in both scenarios, not invested. The monthly extra in the invest/save scenario is still invested throughout. That is not a like-for-like comparison and usually favours investing/saving, so treat the result with care.
You have changed an input. Press Calculate to update these results.

Net position over time

Net position is investments or savings minus any mortgage still owed.

What if returns are higher or lower?

Only the investment return changes in each row. The mortgage rate, charges, tax and amounts stay as you entered them.

How this calculator works: It runs two scenarios month by month using the same cash out every month. In the overpay scenario your lump sum and monthly extra go to the mortgage and the payment stays the same, so the mortgage clears sooner. In the invest/save scenario you pay only your scheduled payment and invest the lump sum and monthly extra. It then compares investments minus mortgage balance for each option on the same date. Lifetime interest saved is shown separately: it runs until each mortgage is fully repaid, which can be later than your comparison date. Payments and contributions are made at the end of each month. Growth is a steady annual return, worked out as (gross return minus charges) less your chosen tax rate, with no tax relief assumed on a negative return. This is a simplified model and not the exact tax treatment of any account or investment. Tax on withdrawal, early repayment charges, rate changes after a fixed deal and interest-only or buy-to-let mortgages are not modelled.

Overpay Mortgage or Invest/Save Calculator

Should spare money go towards your mortgage or into savings and investments? This Overpay Mortgage or Invest/Save Calculator compares the two using your own numbers. It weighs the interest you would save by overpaying against what the same money could grow to elsewhere after tax and charges, then compares both options on the same date.

This is a different question from how much interest an overpayment saves. The Mortgage Overpayment Calculator shows the interest and time saved, while this calculator asks whether that saving beats the alternative.

How the comparison works

  1. Same cash in both scenarios. Every month you pay out the same total amount in both options: your mortgage payment plus any monthly extra.
  2. Overpay scenario. Your lump sum and monthly extra go to the mortgage and your payment stays the same, so the mortgage is cleared sooner.
  3. Invest/save scenario. You pay only your scheduled mortgage payment and invest the lump sum and monthly extra.
  4. Freed-up payments. Once a mortgage is cleared, the money that was going to it is invested. This keeps the comparison fair.
  5. Net position. For each option the calculator works out investments minus any mortgage still owed, on the same date, and compares them.

Lifetime interest saved versus overall advantage

Lifetime interest saved is the mortgage interest you avoid if you overpay, counted until each mortgage is fully repaid. That can run past the date you choose to compare. The overall advantage is the difference in net position on the comparison date, which also includes the investment growth you give up by overpaying. The two figures answer different questions, so the calculator shows both, along with the interest saved by the comparison date.

What the break-even return tells you

The break-even return is the net annual return, after tax and charges, at which both options finish level. It is found by repeatedly testing returns in the same month-by-month model until the difference is zero. A higher assumed return than the break-even favours investing or saving on your inputs, and a lower one favours overpaying. When freed-up payments are invested, the break-even net return matches the effective annual rate of your mortgage interest, so overpaying behaves like a return equal to your mortgage rate for as long as that rate applies.

Factors this calculator does not decide for you

  • Early repayment charges and overpayment limits: not modelled. Check your mortgage terms before overpaying.
  • Access to your money: money overpaid on a mortgage is usually hard to get back, while savings and investments can generally be accessed.
  • Risk: overpaying saves interest at your mortgage rate while that rate applies. Investment returns are uncertain and can fall as well as rise.
  • Emergency savings: many people keep a cash buffer before overpaying or investing.
  • Tax wrappers and allowances: the tax rate you choose is a simplification. See the ISA Calculator and the Savings Interest Tax Calculator.
  • Changing mortgage rates: the calculator uses one rate throughout. Re-run it with a different rate to test a change.

Limits of this calculator

This calculator is for residential repayment mortgages. It does not cover interest-only or buy-to-let mortgages, early repayment charges, tax on withdrawals, or changes in your mortgage rate. Returns are applied as a steady annual figure, whereas real returns vary from year to year. Results are illustrative estimates and not financial advice. Consider speaking to a regulated adviser or your lender before making a decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it better to overpay my mortgage or invest?

It depends on your mortgage rate compared with the return you actually achieve after tax and charges, and on how much risk and lack of access you are comfortable with. Overpaying saves interest at your mortgage rate, which is certain only while that rate applies. Investment returns are not guaranteed. This calculator compares the two using your own figures. It does not tell you which to choose.

How does the comparison work?

Both scenarios use the same cash out every month. In the overpay scenario your lump sum and monthly extra go to the mortgage and the payment stays the same, so the mortgage clears sooner. In the invest/save scenario you pay only your scheduled payment and invest the lump sum and monthly extra. The calculator then compares investments minus mortgage balance for each scenario on the same date.

What is net position?

Net position is the value of your investments or savings minus any mortgage balance still owed on the comparison date. It lets the two scenarios be compared fairly, because one may have a smaller mortgage and the other a larger pot.

Why are freed-up mortgage payments invested?

Once the overpay scenario clears the mortgage, the money that was going to the mortgage is free. If that money were ignored, the comparison would unfairly favour investing from the start. By default the calculator invests freed-up payments in both scenarios, so both options use the same cash each month. You can turn this off, but the result will usually then favour investing/saving.

What is the break-even return?

The break-even return is the net annual return, after tax and charges, at which overpaying and investing/saving finish with the same net position. It is found numerically using the same month-by-month model. If your assumed net return is above it, investing/saving finishes ahead on your inputs. If it is below, overpaying finishes ahead. The calculator also shows the approximate gross return needed before tax and charges. If none is found within the range tested, which is net returns from -99% to 500% a year, it says so and does not claim that no break-even exists at all.

Why is lifetime mortgage interest saved different from the overall advantage?

Lifetime interest saved adds up the mortgage interest you avoid by overpaying until each mortgage is fully repaid, which can be later than your comparison date. The calculator also shows the interest saved by the comparison date. The overall advantage is measured only on the comparison date, as the difference in net position, and also counts the growth you would have earned by investing or saving the same money after tax and charges. A large interest saving can still be outweighed by strong investment growth, and the reverse can also be true.

Does this include early repayment charges or overpayment limits?

No. Many mortgage deals limit how much you can overpay without an early repayment charge, and these terms differ between lenders and products. Check your own mortgage terms or ask your lender before overpaying.

How is tax on investment growth treated?

You choose an effective tax rate that is applied to growth each year, or choose no tax for a tax-free wrapper such as an ISA. Net return is calculated as gross return minus charges, then reduced by the tax rate if the result is positive. No tax relief is assumed on losses. This is a simplified model and not the exact tax treatment of any account or investment. Real tax depends on the product and your circumstances, and tax on withdrawal is not modelled, so treat the result as an estimate.

Can I use this for an interest-only or buy-to-let mortgage?

No. This calculator is for residential repayment mortgages. Interest-only mortgages need a different model, and buy-to-let mortgages involve different tax treatment of interest.

Does it allow for my mortgage rate changing?

No. It uses the single mortgage rate you enter for the whole comparison. If your rate is likely to change, for example when a fixed deal ends, run the calculator again with a different rate to see how the result moves.