Job Offer Comparison Calculator
Enter two offers, or add a third. Fields marked optional can be left blank.
About you (applies to every offer)
Job Offer Comparison Calculator UK
Comparing job offers by salary alone can be misleading. Two offers with the same headline pay can leave you with very different amounts once Income Tax, National Insurance, student loan repayments, pension arrangements and the cost of getting to work are taken into account. This job offer comparison calculator estimates what each offer is worth to you in a single, transparent comparison.
What the calculator compares
- Estimated take-home pay, annually and monthly, after Income Tax, National Insurance, student loan repayments and your own pension contribution.
- Employer pension contribution, shown separately because it is paid into your pension rather than your bank account.
- Annual additional costs, such as commuting and other work-related costs you enter.
- Benefits you value, entered by you in pounds, so nothing is valued on your behalf.
- Effective annual value, which combines the figures above into one comparison number.
How pensions are treated
Pensions are the easiest part of a job offer to get wrong, so the calculator separates three things. Your own contribution is deducted from take-home pay. The employer contribution is not take-home pay. And the method used to collect your contribution changes the tax result: net pay arrangements, relief at source and salary sacrifice are each modelled on their own rules. Check with the employer which method applies to the pension scheme in each offer.
Break-even salary
If one offer has a lower effective annual value, the calculator estimates the base pay it would need to match the best offer. The figure comes from re-running the full calculation with a higher salary, not from a flat tax-rate shortcut, and it is only an estimate under the assumptions you entered.
What is not included
The calculator does not value holiday entitlement automatically and does not model equity or share options, benefits in kind such as company cars or private medical cover, tax code adjustments, or differences in the cost of living between locations. For some of these, see the related calculators below.
Rates and official sources
The calculator uses a single dated set of 2026/27 rates, shown in the assumptions section under the results. You can check the official figures on GOV.UK for Income Tax rates, Scottish Income Tax, National Insurance rates and student loan repayments.
Things to weigh beyond the numbers
- Job security and the strength of the employer
- Hours, flexibility and where you will be working
- Holiday entitlement and sick pay terms
- Training, progression and the nature of the work
- Probation periods, notice periods and bonus conditions
Frequently Asked Questions
How does the Job Offer Comparison Calculator work?
Enter the pay, bonus, pension terms and work-related costs for two or three offers. The calculator estimates take-home pay for each one using Income Tax, National Insurance and student loan rules, then adds employer pension contributions and any benefits you value, and subtracts the extra costs of the job. The result is an estimated effective annual value for each offer.
What is effective annual value?
Effective annual value is a personal comparison figure: estimated take-home pay plus the employer pension contribution plus the pound value you put on any benefits, minus your annual work-related costs. You can also choose to count your own pension contributions. It is not a payslip figure and it depends on the values you enter.
What is the difference between net pay, relief at source and salary sacrifice?
With a net pay arrangement your contribution is taken before Income Tax, but National Insurance and student loan repayments are still worked out on your full pay. With relief at source you pay from pay that has already been taxed, and your provider adds basic-rate relief. With salary sacrifice you agree to a lower salary, so Income Tax, National Insurance and student loan repayments are all worked out on the lower figure. The calculator treats each method separately because they give different take-home results.
Why are employer pension contributions not included in take-home pay?
Employer contributions are paid into your pension, not into your bank account, so they are shown on their own line. They are added to effective annual value because they are part of what the job is worth to you, but they never appear in the take-home figure.
How is the break-even salary worked out?
The calculator finds the extra base pay a lower-valued offer would need to reach the same effective annual value as the highest-valued offer. It does this by repeatedly re-running the full tax, National Insurance, student loan and pension calculation with a higher salary until the two values match. Everything else about that offer stays the same, so treat the result as an estimate under your assumptions.
Does the calculator value holiday entitlement, equity or company cars?
No. Holiday entitlement is not valued automatically, and equity or share options and benefits in kind such as company cars or private medical cover are not taxed or modelled. If you want a benefit to count, enter your own pound value for it in the optional benefits section. Any benefit that is taxable as a benefit in kind is not adjusted for tax.
Which tax year and rates does the calculator use?
The calculator uses 2026/27 tax year rules for England, Wales and Northern Ireland and for Scotland, along with National Insurance and student loan thresholds for the same year. The Tax year and assumptions section under the results shows the exact figures used and the date they were last reviewed. Official rates are published on GOV.UK.
Should I choose the job offer with the highest effective annual value?
Not necessarily. The figure only reflects the money values you entered. Job security, career development, hours, flexibility, commute time, holiday and the work itself also matter, and none of them are captured in a single number. Use the result as one input to your decision.
Why might my payslip differ from the estimate?
Payroll works out Income Tax, National Insurance and student loan repayments each pay period using your tax code, so real deductions can differ from an annual estimate, particularly if a bonus is paid in a single month, your tax code includes adjustments, or you have other income. The calculator gives an illustrative estimate, not a payroll calculation.
This calculator provides illustrative estimates for general information only. It is not financial, tax, legal or employment advice. Check important decisions with a qualified adviser and the employer.